Monday, September 15, 2008

Response Three

McCloud shows the different ways that cartoons show the elapse of time. This is done with frame size or text in most cases but in the case of Zombie and Mummy the creator uses how the viewer scrolls the screen to break the time frames into sequence. I think that it is a more modern and perhaps better way for the viewer to understand the concept of time changing and scene change. The viewer cannot see the previous frame when reading the current scene and that gives not only a implied time lapse but a more physical idea of time. The scrolling also aides in the sequence that the cartoon flows. Rather than having multiple scenes on one page and having the viewer follow the scene in hopefully the right order, the viewer has no choice but to read in the order that the cartoons appear on the page. Idea of sequential writing does not always mean that the story must follow a single plot line. With Carl Stories the viewer can create many different story lines to end up with the end of the story. Choosing the longest or shortest path to the end. This is breaking apart the idea of the cartoon story following frame after frame till the end. Geniwaite uses this idea in a way with The Night of Melvin’s Murder. With the link associated with the characters name and phrases. If the reader chose to click the link not in the order of the text but instead in a random fashion they would be reading a different story altogether. By choosing which one to click and when, as the reader clicks the links they find out pieces of the story in different orders, so each reader will get the story in a totally different way. Both time frame and sequence can change the way a viewer understands and perceives a story.

3 comments:

Gwendolyn said...

The two pieces you chose to look at have interesting contrasts. One chooses a path for the reader, and the other gives the reader the opportunity to choose his or her own path. I think these choices say something interesting about the authors, showing one may potentially need more narrative control than the other.

Terri said...

Good points about the night of Melvin's murder and time frames and sequence. It definitely shows the infinite possibilities and creativity involved with comics.

elizabethany said...

Great thinking when it comes to the Zombie and Mummy. I looked at it and got so confused on how to relate it to Mccloud's text but I think you did a great job. The idea of not having all of the scenes visible, and having to create that lapse in time on your own is great. McCloud does have a way of directing everyone very specifically but all of the examples we looked at in class leave it more up to the reader, their imagination, and what they decide to click or look at.

Good job :)